Learn to bake sourdough bread - the best bread in the world!

Experimenting with two Alaskan Starters

I have two Alaskan starters, one is the one I sell and it is a very fast starter taking only about 3 – 3.5 hours to double. The second one is 106 years old and is a different story. I will tell you about it. I wasn’t having the same success with the 106 year old starter as with the first starter so I decided to do an experiment to see why. I made up a batter with 4 oz flour, 4 oz water and 3 oz starter(the starer was at 166% hydration). That came to approximately 114% hydration for the batter(which is a way of saying how thick the batter is). I carefully measured out both starter batters into quart jars and labeled their starting time with a line and their name. Here are the starters at the beginning of the experiment:


Two starters

Alaska # 1 doubled by 3.5 hours and went to 4.5 hours before it finally collapsed back to the third hour mark.


As you have already noticed by now, Alaska starter # 2 did not budge at all ! Shocking! I decided to see if what it liked was a lower hydration. I added approx 2 Tablespoons of flour to the existing batter which was at 114% hydration. That brought it to approx. 109% hydration. What happened is truly amazing. After eight hours it finally looked like this:

Alaska 2

Unbelievably, this morning it was still going strong at 18 hours later:

Alaska 2

It has even grown another 1/4 inch up the jar since I took the picture an hour ago. Which means it is now growing faster. This raises some interesting observations.

It may have seemed as if  Alaska # 2 was a dead starter, but I knew it wasn’t. Doing an experiment like this can let you know what is going on and the potential of the starter. When I tried to make waffle batter with this starter it made a heavier waffle, now I know why. Some of the things I CAN do with this starter is to make biscuits the night before and have them nicely risen the next morning, and I am going to try that! You can have a long fermented bread dough and it should last a very long time. As a matter of fact , if you tried to follow a regular timed recipe with this starter , it wouldn’t do very well. This starter obviously likes a lower hydration dough and not a batter.

Another point I would like to make is that I have had these two starters for some time and they are without a doubt two different starters. They did not become the same starter by feeding with the same flour, as some people believe. That is a fallacy that some people who have not actually experimented with starters believe. I have many different starters and even over a long period of time, as long as I have not cross contaminated them by using the same mixing spoon,etc, they still have their own unique characteristics. I think that there can be organisms in the flour already that can help you get a starter going, however, a batter that is actually innoculated with a particular starter, should have the introduced starter take over and keep out any competition. That would be because the amount of the organisms in the innoculation starter would overwhelm any in the flour. A similar comparison would be a yogurt bacteria. If you innoculate a container of milk with a yogurt bacteria, you would then have that yogurt from then on, and not whatever organism that might have taken over which was already in the milk. If a starter is kept healthy by regular feeding and care, it should be strong enought to keep out any competition. It is when the container gets dirty, the starter is not fed, and the acidity of the starter is compromised that another organisim can take over. Also care is needed in culturing a new starter or rehydrating a new starer until the starter is strong and bubbly, another organism can take over. I know this is a controversial subject in the sourdough world, so any feedback or experience you have will be appreciated.

Thanks to Gary Taylor for help with hydration!

Similar posts
  • Fresh Ground Flour and Home MillingI have two home mills, the Blendtec Kitchen Mill and the Mockmill, well maybe three if you count the cheapo coffee grinder I used in the past before I got the Mockmill. The Blendtec Kitchen Mill has been a mainstay in my kitchen for years. I’m actually on my second one as the first one ended [...]
  • Sweet and Sour SourdoughIt’s that time of year when lots of folks around the world are baking. We are heading into spring in this hemisphere and on the other side of the world they are heading into fall. Often in the summer many people give up baking for a while, so during summer half the world isn’t as [...]
  • Failure in Bread BakingI would like to mention something. I have baking failures. We all do. Those of you who are newbies sometimes get discouraged by seeing other baker’s photos, but all of us, even now, will have failures, we just don’t post them for the world to [...]
  • Time and Temperature Experiments with Modified Glute...Hello everyone! I’ve been experimenting with time and temperatures from the Modified Bread formula from my course “Extreme Fermentation.” What’s really great about this bread is that you can do endless experiments to find out what the bread will do, especially since the batch is [...]
  • Christmas Giveaway 2016  Edited to name winners:  Dianna  dallidallibakery – Brod and Taylor proofer Lindsay Leong – Mockmill Vanya Dineva – Lame by Zatoba Arie Arie@***shine.com – Fibrament Baking Stone David [email protected] – KD8000 Baker’s Scale Winners please contact me at [email protected] by Dec 31st to claim your prize and give me your address so the sponsors [...]


  1. Molly Molly
    April 27, 2014    

    Wow pretty amazing read! And I like your inference (existing organisms vs newly introduced organisms!).. I’m going to be a regular haunt here!! Your mind is incredible! Thank you!

  2. Nhut Tran Nhut Tran
    June 23, 2012    

    I am still learning. I am new to the world of sourdough cultures/starters. I interested very much in making sourdough starter and I like to bake them one day. I am taking some baking and cooking courses at MPC.
    I like baking more than cooking. Thank you so very much for a wonderful website that you are now have. I enjoy so much. I like the way you write and express more details and completely easy clear English.
    I wish I can shake your hand and say thank a million. I have spent so much time and papers to copy down documents about how to make sourdough starters. It took me more than a year now.
    Thank God I finally found it and
    Thank you to you a lot to Northwestsourdough.com.

    Nhut Tran

  3. Jolynn Jolynn
    September 11, 2006    

    I also have kept numerous starters over the years, each of which seemed happiest at different hydrations/temperatures. I would be curious to see how your starter #1 did at a lower hydration and what effect temperture has on them both. I’ve recently begun using a levain rather than a batter type consistency for my starters and find I have a little more leeway with proof time (they’re less likely to oversour) and they store a little longer in the frige before going dormant. It would be interesting to do some side by side comparisons. Thanks for the inspiration!

  4. KathyB KathyB
    September 8, 2006    

    I have two strains of starters, both originated in Italy, one was captured ‘wild’in an outdoor setting, the other was captured in a very old bread baking shop. Like your two different starters, these have quite different lengths of time to become active and it is the one from that older bread shop that takes longer. Maybe ‘mature’ cultures just naturally take longer?

  5. Bill44 Bill44
    September 7, 2006    

    Considering the age of the starter it may well be of the type that Alaskan “Sourdoughs” used to keep in a roll around there body. Obviously it would have needed to be at a low hydration to be able to do this, thus explaining its low hydration preference.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discovering Sourdough, The Books:

Discovering Sourdough - The bread books!
Only 10-15 dollars  
Favorite Bread Baking Equipment